Forum | Let the games begin!

Current User: Guest
Please consider registering

Search Forums:


 






Let the games begin!

UserPost

3:50 pm
November 24, 2008


Earl Blake

Moderator

posts 9

 
1

DxO Labs has created a website that mesures and ranks only the camera's raw image quality.  This should put an end to all the "My camera is better than your camera." This will show that Nikon is far supperior to Canon! :-)


http://www.dxomark.com/

4:18 pm
November 24, 2008


Geren Mortensen

Columbia, Maryland, USA

Admin

posts 60

 
2

Well, lessee … Based on the random cameras on the front page of the site, the three year old Canon 5D is only a small percentage behind the Nikon D3, as far as RAW IQ is concerned. Since the D700 uses basically the same sensor and processing as the D3, and based on what I've seen from the pre-production samples, the RAW IQ of the Canon 5DMkII is going to blow the D3 and D700 right out of the water.

I also ran a few checks on their system, and have found at least one issue — I'm left wondering how a camera that processes RAW data at 12-bits can have better color depth than one that processes RAW data a 14-bits. The math doesn't hold true. Of course, DxO are the folks who worked behind the scenes on Nikon's RAW processing software, so I could guess they might be a little biased — more Nikon units sold=more DxO software sold? Hmmm…

That said … I think that the images from the original 5D, the D3, the D700 and even the Canon 1DsMkII have a better subjective image quality than the Canon 5DMkII and the 1DsMkIII. I think we've reached a point where things might be too good.

Geren W. Mortensen, Jr. – WebMaster – CMPG

2:27 pm
January 30, 2010


slothead

Snapshotter

posts 14

 
3

I thought it was interesting data too Geren.  I compared my 3 Nikons, and my PPS (Practically Point and Shoot) D5000 was better in most characteristics than my D300 and D300S!  Obviously there are some other attributes that the 300s do better than the 5000, but still it was eye-opening.

Tom



Reply to Topic:
Let the games begin!

Guest Name (Required):

Guest Email (Required):

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Smileys
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell
Post New Reply

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
3 + 8
   





Print This Page
Email This Page

Next Meeting: July 28th 2010 Room 212/213 Chapelgate Presbyterian Church

Membership Has It's Benefits!
CMPG Members get a 40% discount on all purchases at Harald Heim's The Plugin Site. Visit the Member Benefits Forum to learn more about this and other member benefits.

Not a member yet? Consider joining. CMPG memberships are still only $25 per year.(pro-rated to Jan 1) Read about the advantages of a CMPG membership here.

Recent Gallery Uploads

Coopers Hawk in Florida Coopers Hawk in Florida Coopers Hawk in Florida Florida Wood Stork in flight Florida Wood Stork Lizard in a bush
To see more photography from our members, visit our galleries.

Recent Articles

See more photography from our members by visiting our galleries.

Upcoming Events

No events scheduled at the moment.

For complete information about upcoming CMPG events, visit our Calendar of Events.